She Told Me to Settle Down. I Went to College Instead.

She Told Me to Settle Down. I Went to College Instead.

I can still picture that little office. I was a senior in high school in Orlando, sitting across a metal desk from my guidance counselor. The room was crowded with bookshelves and college brochures. Just signing up for that meeting felt like a big deal. I had hopes and dreams and I believed the woman I had been randomly assigned to was going to help me make them come true. It felt a little like walking up to the Wizard of Oz. I was sure the words I was about to hear would change my life.

I was the only girl in a family of three kids and nobody in my world was talking to me about a career. I wanted an education and a job that would give me choices.

That wasn’t because my parents didn’t care. My dad served in the Korean War and later flew KC-135s during Vietnam. My mom was trained as a nurse. They were capable people who worked hard for our family. They never discouraged me or my brothers from going to college, but they never told us it was a must either. Nobody had laid that groundwork for me, so when I walked into that guidance office I was hoping someone finally would. That didn’t feel like too much to ask. After all, isn’t helping students plan their future the whole point of a guidance counselor?

She saw my future differently. She suggested that a girl like me would be better off finding a job after high school and settling down to start a family. I was caught completely off guard. In her eyes I was only good enough to keep doing the kind of work I had already been doing for the past few years. The whole meeting felt like an assembly line. She knew nothing about me beyond my grades and test scores. In a few short minutes she had sorted me into a box that already had a label on it. Even then I remember thinking, who gave her the right to decide what I could or couldn’t become?

I rushed off to my next class with my stack of textbooks feeling deflated. I had gone in looking for a little encouragement and walked out being told to lower my sights. Lucky for me I have never been very good at letting someone else decide what I’m capable of doing. By 16 I was living on my own and paying my own way with summer nights at Walt Disney World and shifts at Ivy’s Drug Store during the school year. I was not about to let one meeting with a stranger decide the rest of my life.

Not every adult in my life sold me short. Mr. Ivy owned and ran the drug store, and every day he handed me The Wall Street Journal and Barron’s after he finished reading them. He never gave me a speech about my potential. He simply treated a teenage girl working his register like someone who might care about business and the markets. Seriously, who would think a small gesture like that would make such a difference? It did. I still think of him every morning when I pull up the Journal online.

You already know how this story ends. You wouldn’t be reading my blog if I had given up that day and stayed behind the counter at Ivy’s forever. I got into the University of Central Florida and kept plugging along. I kept my job at the drug store the whole way through and it was not an easy road. There were plenty of moments when I could have quit and settled into the quiet domestic life that counselor had pictured for me. I didn’t. It took me four and a half years to graduate from UCF and I have never been prouder of a piece of paper.

The Part That Still Bothers Me

I was stubborn enough to prove her wrong. But how many other girls sat in that same chair and believed her? How many walked out of that office and quietly let a dream go? I picture those dreams landing on the guidance office floor to be swept up and thrown out at the end of the day. I can’t help wondering who those students might have become.

I wish I could say this was a story from another era. Years later my own children went through high school in a different part of the world and I watched it happen again. My son had a near perfect ACT score and a transcript full of A’s in advanced classes with great AP scores. His dream was to go to the best school he could. His guidance counselor suggested he look at a smaller third tier college instead. Like his mother he refused to settle for bad advice. He was accepted to six of the top ten schools on the U.S. News list and chose Yale. My daughter got the same lower your sights message and she refused it too. She graduated Phi Beta Kappa from SMU. When I shared this with friends I heard their versions of the same story over and over.

What This Means for Leaders

I have spent more than 30 years in the pharmaceutical industry and most of that time leading people. I started leading sales representatives as a district manager at Upjohn. I was often the only woman in the meeting. Over the years I have hired and developed managers who went on to senior leadership roles of their own. One of them became a CEO. Over and over I have watched people accomplish things someone once told them they couldn’t do. Sometimes all it takes is one person who believes in you. Sadly, it can take years to get past the one person who didn’t.

When you are in a position of influence your words carry more weight than you may realize. That is true for teachers and coaches and it is every bit as true for managers. Your employees listen closely to what you say about their potential. An offhand comment in a performance review or a hallway conversation can stay with someone for years.

I’m not suggesting we tell everyone they can do anything without putting in the work. I’m not in favor of participation trophies. Sometimes the kindest thing a leader can do is be honest about the gap between where someone is and where they want to go. But there is a big difference between “here’s what it will take” and “this isn’t for people like you.” The first one builds people up. The second one quietly closes doors. And sometimes opening a door is as simple as handing someone the morning paper.

I Am Not the Only One

After thinking about my own experience I started to wonder how many other people had a story like mine. I was overwhelmed by what I found. A future First Lady was told she wasn’t Princeton material. A future Supreme Court Justice was told not to set her sights so high. A farm girl who dreamed of building spaceships was told to marry a farmer and have children, and she went on to fly in space five times. That last one hit very close to home.

Here are some of those stories.

Person What they were told What they went on to do
Michelle Obama A college counselor told her she wasn’t sure she was “Princeton material.” Graduated from Princeton and Harvard Law School and became First Lady of the United States.
Ketanji Brown Jackson When she said she wanted to go to Harvard, her guidance counselor warned her not to set her sights “so high.” Graduated from Harvard and Harvard Law School and became a Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court.
Condoleezza Rice After a low PSAT score, her guidance counselor told her, “Perhaps you should consider junior college.” Earned a PhD, became provost of Stanford and served as U.S. Secretary of State.
Bonnie Dunbar Her career counselor said that since she grew up on a farm she should marry a farmer and have children. Earned a PhD, flew five Space Shuttle missions and later led Seattle’s Museum of Flight.
Bob Chapek As a freshman he told his counselor he wanted to go to college. She scoffed and told him to go work in the oil refinery like his father and grandfather. Earned a degree from Indiana University and an MBA and became CEO of The Walt Disney Company.
Shonda Rhimes Her counselor told her “not everybody can be Hannah,” pointing to a friend who had gone to Harvard the year before, and said she wouldn’t get into the schools she wanted. Graduated from Dartmouth, created Grey’s Anatomy and Scandal and founded Shondaland.
Jim VandeHei His guidance counselor said he wasn’t cut out for college and suggested trade school or the Army. Started at a two year school, finished at UW–Oshkosh and cofounded Politico and Axios.
Donald Johanson His counselor told him he wasn’t college material and should apply to a trade school. Earned a PhD and discovered “Lucy,” the 3.2-million-year-old human ancestor.
Robert Reffkin His counselor told him not to even apply to Columbia because it wasn’t worth the application fee. Graduated from Columbia in two and a half years and founded the real estate company Compass.
Christopher Rim His counselor told him not to waste his time applying to Yale and urged him to apply to the state school instead. Graduated from Yale and founded the admissions firm Command Education.
David Gyertson His counselor encouraged him to drop out of high school and find work in the gold mines or lumber yards. Served as president of three universities: Asbury, Taylor and Regent.
Donald Caudill A guidance counselor in Southwest Virginia told him he was not college material. Graduated from Berea College, earned a doctorate from Virginia Tech and became a business professor.
Indigo Johnson When she said she wanted to go to college her counselor answered, “You’re not college material.” Founded the HR consulting firm Careers In Transition.
Shana Sanders A guidance counselor in East Cleveland told her she was not college material. Earned bachelor’s and master’s degrees and founded the tech education nonprofit We Create Tech.
Lester Wrobel His high school counselor labeled him “not college material.” Graduated from Penn College and became an automation engineer at the New Jersey utility PSEG.
Doris Webster Her counselor told her she was not college material and placed her in secretarial classes. Built a career and earned her degree from Cleveland State University at age 70.

These accounts are each person’s own recollection, drawn from their memoirs, interviews, speeches and university profiles. They are not an independent record of the counselor’s exact words. Success takes many forms and college is not the only path. The point is that no young person’s future should be decided in a ten minute meeting by someone who barely knows them.

Dream a Little Bigger

I’ve wondered what my counselor would think if she saw how my career turned out. I’d like to believe she would be happy for me. More than that I hope that somewhere along the way she started telling young women to dream a little bigger. So here is my question for every leader reading this. Who on your team is sitting across the desk from you right now, waiting to hear what you think they can become?

–Sheri Staak

PUT IT INTO PRACTICE Free · 5 decisions a day
WOW OR DUD?
Step into a new manager’s shoes and make the tough calls. Some choices are obvious DUDs. Some are almost WOW. Can you find the WOW move?
Sheri Staak
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Sheri Staak has spent more than 30 years leading pharmaceutical sales teams and developing new leaders. She is the author of Tune In to WOW Leadership.

More about Sheri ›Follow on LinkedIn ›

Share this story

Author: Sheri Staak

Sheri Staak is a pharmaceutical executive, author of Tune In to WOW Leadership and a mentor to new and emerging leaders. For more than 30 years she has led sales teams and major business relationships across the industry.

Comments are disabled.